![]() |
In the real world: Amaro is one of the three best tight ends available this year, and he lands in a very good job situation. The New York Jets, who haven't had a tight end since the days when Dustin Keller was healthy, drafted him in Round 2. Jets fans will be thrilled to know that offensive coordinator Marty Mornhinweg thinks of Amaro as a "new toy" to be used a lot, in contrast to the Band-Aids that the Jets used at tight end last year (Jeff Cumberland and a washed-up Kellen Winslow II). |
| In the TUFF world: The Ground Hogs traded TE Vernon Davis to New Orleans earlier in the Draft when they moved up to get RB Bishop Sankey. It looks like they found his replacement right here. Between Amaro and Tyler Eifert (acquired from Carolina last October), the Ground Hogs should have a strong tight end duo for years to come. |
2.07 Green Bay Ground Hogs - TE Jace Amaro
2.08 Carolina Convicts - QB Blake Bortles
![]() |
In the real world: The Jacksonville Jaguars, after giving Blaine Gabbert chance after chance after chance to succeed as an NFL QB, selected Bortles with the third overall pick in the NFL Draft. Bortles has prototypical size, the ability to brush off the rush and keep plays alive (a la Ben Roethlisberger), and a track record for leading his team to victory (road wins against Penn State and Louisville, and he took Central Florida to its first-ever BCS Bowl, the Fiesta Bowl, also a victory over Baylor). After the Fiesta Bowl, his draft stock rose steadily. ESPN's Ron Jaworski ranked him #1 on his list of this year's QBs. Bortles is arguably the rawest of the "Big 3" quarterbacks in this year's draft, however--he worked out of the shotgun in an offense predicated on short passes. |
| In the TUFF world: Going into Round 2, I had penciled in RB Charles Sims to the Cons (Doug Martin handcuff), but I had assumed that Bortles would be gone long before this pick. Bortles makes perfect sense for the Cons. Alex Smith is 30 years old and always seems to have someone looking over his shoulder these days, the next-best QB on the roster (Michael Vick) will be 34 next month and seems resigned to serving as a veteran backup/mentor for Geno Smith, and the other two QBs (Matt Barkley, Matt Flynn) are question marks. |
2.09 Baltimore Brown Clowns - RB Charles Sims
![]() |
In the real world: The Tampa Bay Buccaneers added the versatile Sims to add depth to a backfield headed up by lead dog Doug Martin, who is returning from a shoulder injury; and Bobby Rainey, their waiver wire find from last year. Rainey will become a restricted free agent after 2014. Sims is one of the draft's best pass-catching backs and he consistently produced in college. |
| In the TUFF world: The Brown Clowns continued their efforts to patch up their backfield here. |
2.10 Indy Hoosier Daddy's - RB Lache Seastrunk
![]() |
In the real world: Seastrunk was very productive in his years at Baylor. For whatever reason, instead of being picked up by a team that needed a running back, he ended up falling to Round 6 to a team that already has Alfred Morris and Roy Helu. He needs to work on catching passes; he had more dropped passes (10) than receptions (9) during his two-year college career. |
| In the TUFF world: Getting depth at RB is fine--for those of you keeping score at home, 12 backs went in the first 26 picks. But in my estimation, Indy could use better quality depth at WR beyond Eric Decker, James Jones and DeSean Jackson (I thought they'd take someone like Cody Latimer or Allen Robinson). T.J. Graham and Quinton Patton haven't done much. (Stephen Hill has been a disappointment, but at least now he serves as a handcuff in case Decker gets hurt.) |
2.11 Houston Tethered Swimmers - WR Jarvis Landry
![]() |
In the real world: Landry comes to a Miami Dolphins team that needs depth at wide receiver. His terrible Combine and lackluster pro day performances should have hurt his draft stock, but judging by the fact that the 'Fins took him late in Round 2, it didn't get hurt too badly. In fairness, Landry outproduced the more heralded Odell Beckham last year. NFL Network's Mike Mayock went so far as to say he couldn't tell Landry from Beckham when watching them in games, and added that Landry was the toughest wideout in this year's class. |
| In the TUFF world: The run on backs earlier in this draft might have tempted Houston to take De'Anthony Thomas and handcuff him to Jamaal Charles. Kudos to Jeff Rathburn for resisting that temptation and taking a better overall player. It's time to move on past Davone Bess, Donnie Avery and Vincent Brown. |
2.12 Green Bay Ground Hogs - WR Cody Latimer
![]() |
In the real world: Latimer impressed everyone at the NFL Combine by benching the most reps by a WR with 23. He also ran in the high 4.3's at his pro day and also jumped 39 inches in the vertical. He was very productive on the field, catching 72 passes for 1,096 yards in 2013 for Indiana despite the fact that, hey, they didn't have much of a team around him. He brings his size-speed combo to a high-powered offense*. Note: He is still recovering from foot surgery.
*Never mind that he might not get to play a whole lot with Peyton Manning before Manning hangs up the cleats and joins CBS' The NFL Today as a studio analyst. |
| In the TUFF world: Green Bay's already rich, young wideout corps just got richer and younger. It'll be interesting to see, though, what the Ground Hogs will do at quarterback in Week 4, given that they passed up Derek Carr here, and Blake Bortles earlier in this round. Maybe they're going to use that A-11 offense the Detroit Vipers so successfully used against Arizona in Week 5 last year. Speaking of those Vipers... |
2.16 New Orleans Chocolate City - WR Josh Huff
![]() |
In the real world: The Philadelphia Eagles took Huff in Round 3 of the NFL Draft; he played under their head coach, Chip Kelly, at Oregon. He had a very good offseason, performing well during Senior Bowl week and showing sub-4.5 speed. He may be the Eagles' #4 wide receiver already, given that DeSean Jackson and Jason Avant are gone. As mentioned back at 1.15, Jeremy Maclin could leave after this year. In the meantime, however, targets won't be easy to come by this year, with Maclin returning from injury, Darren Sproles arriving from New Orleans, second-year TE Zach Ertz due for an expanded role, and fellow rookie Jordan Matthews arriving fresh out of Vanderbilt. Given his size, speed and athleticism, he could play a few different roles--he could be used as a kick returner or a running back as well as a wideout. |
| In the TUFF world: This pick is good considering this spot in the Draft. It'll be interesting to see how Kelly uses Huff. Only time will tell what role he will play, and how much of a role that will be. |
2.13 Detroit Vipers - WR Allen Robinson
![]() |
In the real world: By taking Marqise Lee and Allen Robinson, the Jacksonville Jaguars showed that they plan to move on without their 2012 first-round pick, Justin Blackmon. Robinson can be tough to cover in the red zone, but he may be more of a possession receiver. (Then again, some people said the same about Anquan Boldin 11 years ago, and he's had an extremely productive career for a #2.) Former NFL scout Russ Lande has gone so far as to compare Robinson to the Houston Texans' Andre Johnson. The question is, what weight and speed will he bring to training camp? He ran a disappointing 4.60 40 at the Combine, but after losing 12 pounds, he ran a 4.47 at his Pro Day. He will have to battle Lee, Cecil Shorts, and Ace Sanders for receptions this year, but Shorts (who comes of an injury-marred 2013 season) will become a free agent after 2014. |
| In the TUFF world: The Vipers certainly feel the Jaguars' pain--both have WR depth issues exacerbated by Blackmon's problems. Detroit had been planning to take a wideout in Round 2 all along, after passing up Marqise Lee in favor of QB Johnny Manziel back in Round 1. Many fantasy football writers put Allen Robinson squarely in the top 10 among rookie wideouts, with some putting him in the top 20 among overall players. As with Latimer and Lee, this is a very good value pick. | |
![]() |
Lucky Number 29? If Robinson is a hit, it wouldn't be the first time this franchise found a top-tier wide receiver with the 29th overall pick. The same thing happened in 2005, when they landed Vincent Jackson. Not only that, but Robinson and Jackson went at the exact same spot in their respective NFL Drafts--the 29th pick on the second round (61st overall). |
2.14 Pittsburgh BIG PAPAS - RB Marion Grice
![]() |
In the real world: The Chargers took Grice out of Arizona State in Round 6. Their top two RBs are Ryan Mathews and Donald Brown, both of whom are no stranger to injuries. Then again, Grice himself is not yet fully recovered from a broken leg suffered late in the 2013 season. |
| In the TUFF world: I praised Pittsburgh for drafting Marqise Lee instead of reaching to fill their RB depth need at 2.06, and they also took Odell Beckham at 1.12. They therefore could afford to address their RB depth here, even though I offer this "what if" scenario: One of their starting wideouts is Antonio Brown; why not take Martavis Bryant to handcuff to him? If Brown were to get hurt, Bryant could benefit. |
3.01 Dallas Junglehawgs - WR Martavis Bryant
![]() |
In the real world: Bryant didn't produce much in college, but that's because he was stuck behind star receivers like Sammy Watkins and DeAndre Hopkins. What he does bring to the Pittsburgh Steelers is a terrific size-speed combo (6'4", 211 lb., 4.42 speed, comparable to Cody Latimer in that respect). He'll compete against second-year man Markus Wheaton, free agent arrival Lance Moore and possibly fellow rookie Dri Archer for the receptions Emmanuel Sanders used to get before he went to Denver. Oh, and Ben Roethlisberger likes tall wideouts--he reportedly lobbied for Limas Sweed six years ago. |
| In the TUFF world: Here's who New Orleans should have taken at 2.16. Bryant has the better size-speed combo, rated higher by Scouts, Inc., ranked higher by NFLDraftScout.com, ranked higher by just about everyone on footballguys.com, and a better job situation. I see a key similarity between this pick and Dallas' second-rounder, Donte Moncrief (2.04)--both are boom-or-bust prospects who were inconsistent in college. However much I like this pick, though, I was surprised that Dallas didn't opt for TE Austin Seferian-Jenkins here, then hope for Bryant to fall to 3.04. The Junglehawgs could use an upgrade at tight end. |
3.02 Indy Hoosier Daddy's - QB Derek Carr
![]() |
In the real world: Carr was ranked a distant fourth among this year's crop of signal-callers (behind Bortles, Manziel and Bridgewater) due in part to long-distance accuracy issues. The good news is, he lands in Oakland, and the Raiders use the West Coast offense (which can help mask those issues). Only one man stands in his way over there: Matt Schaub, who looked terrible at times last season, who only cost the Raiders a sixth-round pick to acquire, and whose restructed contract ensures that if he messes up again this season, he'll be cut next year. |
| In the TUFF world: The Green Room can be such a torture chamber after a while. Derek Carr is finally free! Indy may have finally found its backup for Drew Brees with just an early third-round pick. Whatever weaknesses Carr has, they don't matter at this stage of the draft. |
3.03 Tennessee Taz Devils - RB Jerick McKinnon
![]() |
In the real world: McKinnon played quarterback and cornerback as well as running back at Georgia Southern. He starred in Georgia Southern's upset of Florida last year, and then demonstrated some crazy athleticism at the Combine, where he was among the top performers at his position in just about every drill (especially the bench press, where he did 32 reps--six more than the next-best RB). However, he'll need some work in the passing game (next to no pass-blocking experience and only ten career catches). The Vikings drafted him in Round 3 and presently see him as a "change-of-pace" back. For what it's worth, Adrian Peterson will be due a whopping $15 million next year. |
| In the TUFF world: I wonder if this was a homer pick, being that Lonnie's from Georgia and Derick played for a Georgia school. Regardless, it's a good pick. It takes a handcuff away from a division rival (Denver) and if Matt Asiata can produce in the Vikings' offense (remember Week 15 last season?), then maybe McKinnon can. |
3.04 New Orleans Chocolate City - TE Austin Seferian-Jenkins
![]() |
In the real world: The Tampa Bay Buccaneers took Seferian-Jenkins in Round 2 to fill the hole they had at tight end. |
| In the TUFF world: After acquiring Vernon Davis in a trade, I didn't think New Orleans would draft a tight end, but this was a very solid value pick, solidified their depth at the position, and enabled them to jettison the disappointing Brandon Pettigrew (ultra-disappointing when you consider that they acquired him from Detroit in 2010 for RB Reggie Bush). It also prevented Seferian-Jenkins from falling into the laps of the division rival Dallas Junglehawgs. |
3.05 Dallas Junglehawgs - QB Tom Savage
![]() |
In the real world: Savage didn't produce a lot in college, but that was because he transferred twice. He started at Rutgers, transferred to Arizona, lost a season due to transfer rules, but then Rich Rodriguez came over and installed his system over there, transferred again (to Pittsburgh), lost another season, and finally started for Pitt last season. He later said that if he had to do it all again, he would have just stayed at Rutgers. He played well (11 TDs vs 3 INT), and he has a lot of the tools scouts look for in NFL quarterbacks. |
| In the TUFF world: This pick bolsters Dallas' QB |
3.06 New Orleans Chocolate City - QB Logan Thomas
![]() |
In the real world: Thomas looked terrific as a sophomore but became maddeningly inconsistent after that. Bruce Arians, the Arizona Cardinals' head coach, must have seen a lot of Ben Roethlisberger (his QB when he was the Steelers' offensive coordinator) in Thomas, because he took Thomas in Round 4 when most draft experts had him going a round or two later. But he was extremely inconsistent. Last season, he had terrific games against North Carolina and Miami, but only completed 5-of-26 passes against Alabama. |
| In the TUFF world: New Orleans doesn't have the most solid QB duo in the world--Tony Romo just turned 34 and is coming off of back surgery, while Sam Bradford is coming off a torn ACL. However, even with that said, I personally would have let Thomas fall to Arizona and taken a better player. |
3.07 Arizona Outlaws - RB James White
![]() |
In the real world: The New England Patriots drafted White in Round 4, perhaps to give them another plodding inside-the-tackles ballcarrier in the event that Stevan Ridley continues to have fumbling problems. White could end up in a great job situation if he does well and convinces the Pats to let both Ridley and Shane Vereen walk in free agency. |
| In the TUFF world: The Outlaws were denied the chance to handcuff Logan Thomas (3.06) to Carson Palmer. So they turned to the next option--running back depth. |
3.08 Carolina Convicts - RB James Wilder Jr.
![]() |
In the real world: The Cincinnati Bengals signed Wilder, the son of former Buccaneers RB James Wilder, as an undrafted free agent. Wilder was too slow to be drafted (4.83 in the 40-yard dash) and has been arrested a few times. |
| In the TUFF world: Wilder could be the third-string RB if he makes the Bengals' roster and BenJarvus Green-Ellis gets cut. But the lack of speed and the off-field issues turned me off from drafting him, even though I have Giovani Bernard. I'll just pretend that Carolina picked TE Troy Niklas here and took Wilder at 3.14, because that makes more sense. |
3.09 Baltimore Brown Clowns - WR Paul Richardson
![]() |
In the real world: The defending Super Bowl Champion Seattle Seahawks' first selection in the 2014 NFL Draft was Richardson, a speedy but skinny wideout who reminds some of DeSean Jackson. Richardson will need to work on running routes, but he has the potential to be a home-run threat. |
| In the TUFF world: I consider this a great value pick--Richardson was easily the best available player according to the majority of rookie rankings I've seen. Wideouts that go in Round 2 of the NFL Draft don't often fall to Round 3 of the TUFF Draft. Baltimore needed to add at least one young receiver because their top two (Andre Johnson, Larry Fitzgerald) are in their 30s and have a combined 22 seasons of NFL experience between them.
You know how, a few years ago in my 2010 Draft Wrapup, I came across someone who said "Rounds 1-3 is ordering off a menu, Rounds 4-7 are a buffet"? Richardson was one of the last "menu" players--in my opinion, the very last one. From here on out, it's strictly buffet. |
3.10 Indy Hoosier Daddy's - RB Lorenzo Taliaferro
![]() |
In the real world: The Ravens added to their RB depth with Taliaferro, a 6'0", 220-lb. downhill runner from Coastal Carolina. Their starter, Ray Rice, has had well-documented domestic issues; backup Bernard Pierce is coming off a shoulder injury. What do Terrell Davis, Olandis Gary, Mike Anderson, Reuben Droughns, Steve Slaton and Arian Foster all have in common? They played under Gary Kubiak (the Ravens' new offensive coordinator), rushed for 1,000 yards in a season at least once, and were all drafted in the third round or later (or not drafted at all). Taliaferro also did well in pass protection drills during Senior Bowl week. |
| In the TUFF world: Here's a handcuff pick you could smell from a mile away. |
3.11 Minnesota Fats - WR Jeremy Gallon
![]() |
In the real world: The Patriots took Gallon out of Michigan in Round 7. They see him as possibly another Wes Welker--undersized, probably will start out on special teams and work his way up to slot receiver. |
| In the TUFF world: OK, it's a homer pick, I got that. But if the Fats were going to go wideout, Bruce Ellington would have made much more sense. The Fats have Anquan Boldin and Stevie Johnson to handcuff him to. |
3.13 Detroit Vipers - WR Bruce Ellington
![]() |
In the real world: The San Francisco 49ers nabbed Ellington, the cousin of Cardinals running back Andre Ellington, in Round 4. Although he's short for a wide receiver at 5'9", his height, weight and speed are comparable to Randall Cobb of the Green Bay Packers (although, as with most rookie wide receivers, he needs to work on route-running). In front of him right now are Michael Crabtree, veteran Anquan Boldin, and recent trade acquisition Stevie Johnson. |
In the TUFF world: I also considered three other players (Dri Archer and John Brown; faster and smaller players in the T.Y. Hilton mold; and RB De'Anthony Thomas). But those three don't have the physicality of Ellington, who is considered to be one of the best available players at this point by such sources including (but not limited to):
|
3.14 Carolina Convicts - TE Troy Niklas
![]() |
In the real world: The Arizona Cardinals drafted Troy Niklas, by most accounts the draft's fourth-best tight end, in Round 2 of the NFL Draft. They have two other tight ends on the roster at the moment--Rob Housler and John Carlson--but Niklas may be their best one already. The question is, how much will Bruce Arians use him? Housler has only accounted for 1,004 yards and 1 TD in his three seasons in Arizona, but then again, he's not Niklas (Housler didn't have any receptions after Week 14 last season). Niklas is presently recovering from February hernia surgery. |
| In the TUFF world: Carolina needed to find a better backup for Jordan Cameron, and Niklas is a great fit here. You could reason that if Niklas is better than what the Cardinals had at tight end last year (Housler, Jake Ballard, Jim Dray), and given that Bruce Arians used that trio more in the second half last year (44 receptions, 518 yards and 5 TDs combined), then Niklas could be in a great job situation. If only he had landed in a clearer job situation (like Atlanta), he probably would have gone a lot earlier in this draft and other rookie-only drafts. |
3.15 Tampa Bay Meat Goats - RB De'Anthony Thomas
![]() |
In the real world: The Kansas City Chiefs lost Dexter McCluster to the Tennessee Titans in free agency, and it was just after they were really starting use him. In McCluster's final eight games as a Chief, he had 37 receptions for 325 yards and 2 TDs. Multiply that by 2, and that should give you some idea of how Reid would like to use Thomas. Another thing--the current #2 running back for Kansas City, Knile Davis, is still recovering from knee and leg injuries suffered in the playoff loss against the Colts. Thomas has great speed--I'll never forget the TD the "Black Mamba" scored as a true freshman for Oregon in the Rose Bowl two years ago against Wisconsin--but he didn't do much to prove he belonged in the same class as the other backs Oregon has turned out in recent years. |
| In the TUFF world: My guess is, Jeff Rathburn would have loved to have landed Thomas at 3.16 to handcuff to Jamaal Charles. But this is not a cheap shot by Tampa Bay for losing to Houston in TUFF Bowl XIV--they really could use the RB depth. Aside from Zac Stacy and DeMarco Murray, they don't have a lot. |
3.16 Houston Tethered Swimmers - PK Nate Freese
![]() |
In the real world: Last year, Jason Hanson retired from the NFL after more than two decades as the Detroit Lions' starting placekicker. The Lions signed David Akers, but after last season, decided not to re-sign him. They drafted Freese out of Boston College, and he will compete against Giorgio Tavecchio for their placeckicking job this year. Last season, Freese nailed all 20 of his field goal attempts, including two from 50 yards or more. |
| In the TUFF world: Houston has three other kickers, but only one (Alex Henery) has a solid job situation at the moment. |
4.01 Dallas Junglehawgs - WR Devin Street
![]() |
In the real world: The Cowboys drafted Street out of Pittsburgh in Round 5. He's 6'4", but lanky (190 lb.) and with only average speed (4.56 40). As a senior last season, he caught 51 passes for 854 yards and 7 TDs; he missed three games with injuries. It was a mildly disappointing season after catching 73 passes for 954 yards and 5 TDs in his junior season. Russ Lande, a former NFL scout who once wrote for The Sporting News, said in The National Football Post in 2012 that Street would have to add bulk and strength if he wants to be successful against bigger, more physical NFL cornerbacks. |
| In the TUFF world: Welcome to Round 4--low risk, dreams of high rewards. In addition to his height, Street has another thing in his favor: The job situation with the Cowboys. Miles Austin is gone, and Street will compete against Dwayne Harris and Cole Beasley for targets as the Cowboys' #3 WR. Their #1 wideout, Dez Bryant, could become a free agent after 2014 (although the Cowboys would be wise to extend his contract). |
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)





















